How to Make Blue Hawaiian Jello Shots
These Blue Hawaiian jello shots made with Malibu rum are the color of the ocean and taste so delicious you’ll feel like you’re sitting on a tropical beach. They’re perfect to serve with other tropical flavors like Pina Colada jello shots and Strawberry Daiquiri Jello shots.
Whether I’m making jello shots for my own party or to take to someone else’s get-together, they’re one of my favorite party cocktails.
These blue Hawaiian jello shots are a take-off of the bright blue-colored cocktail with the same name.
Just looking at them reminds me of the ocean, and makes me want to head to the beach. Which makes them the perfect addition to any summer get-together!
This post may contain affiliate links. We make a small commission if you buy the products from these links (at no extra cost to you). As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. But we only recommend products we would use ourselves. For more information, click here to see our disclosures.
The original drink is kind of like a blue Pina Colada.
To keep with the pineapple and coconut flavors, these Blue Hawaiian jello shots are made with pineapple juice and Malibu coconut rum along with Blue Curacao and Berry Blue jello.
Pots and Utensils
Here are the supplies you’ll need to make these jello shots:
- 16 2-ounce jello shot cups*
- cookie sheet (optional)
- kettle or pot (for boiling water)
- mixing bowl
- measuring cup
- mini tasting spoons* (optional)
What Size Of Jello Shot Cups Are The Best?
Before you start making your Blue Hawaiian jello shots, you might want to get your jello shot cups ready.
I like to use the 2 ounce jello shot cups that come with lids*.
That way you can stack them in the refrigerator (I always need as much fridge space available as possible when I’m having a party!). And you don’t have to worry about them spilling if they get knocked over before they are set.
Spreading them out on a cookie sheet makes them really easy to move to the fridge when chilling time comes. It also saves your counter from getting jello on it if you happen to spill some.
How to Make Blue Hawaiian Jello Shots
Put the water on to boil.
I like to use an electric kettle* for this. It boils faster and doesn’t take up any stove space (another thing that always seems to be in short supply when I’m getting ready for a party).
Once it is boiling, combine the Berry Blue Jello crystals with 1 cup hot water, making sure to stir until all of the sugar has dissolved.
I use a bowl with a handle and spout*…it makes pouring the jello into the cups much easier when we get to that stage.
How Much Alcohol Do You Put In Jello Shots?
Add 1/4 cup pineapple juice, 1/2 cup Malibu Coconut Rum and 1/4 cup Blue Curacao.
For this step, I combine the pineapple juice, coconut run and blue curacao in a 2-cup measuring cup that you can read from the top*. It makes measuring so much easier!
Put together, the total of these liquids should come to 1 cup.
This is to double-check that I haven’t messed up on my measurements. (Adding in too much liquid will cause the jello not to set).
Pour the jello mixture into the jello cups and they are ready to chill!
You may want to wait until the jello is cool before putting the lids on.
That will prevent condensation from building up on them. It isn’t really a big deal if it does, since it doesn’t hurt the jello. They just look a little nicer without it.
How Long Does It Take Jello Shots To Set In The Fridge?
Refrigerate the jello shots until they are set, about 2 to 4 hours.
The time will vary based on how full you filled the jello shot cups and how cold your refrigerator is.
How Many Jello Shots Are In A Box Of Jello?
One small (3-oz) box of jello makes about 16 2-ounce jello shots depending on how much you put in each cup.
A large (6-oz) box of jello makes about 32 2-ounce jello shots. You would need to double the amounts for the other ingredients in this recipe to make this work.
How Long Do Jello Shots Last?
Jello shots can be stored in the refrigerator for up to a week. Because these ones contain juice, I wouldn’t keep them much longer than that.
Having said that, I find they start to lose flavor after a few days.
So I usually make these jello shots 1 to 2 days before the party. That way I get the benefits of making them in advance but they still taste their best.
How Do You Serve Jello Shots?
For all the people who don’t want to down jello shots the traditional way, I serve my jello shots with mini tasting spoons*.
They are the perfect size for eating out of a jello shot cup.
Other Jello Shot Recipes You Might Like
- Under The Sea Jello Shots Recipe
- Pina Colada Jello Shots
- Strawberry Daiquiri Jello Shots
- The best blue jello shots
Or browse through all of our jello shot recipes for more ideas.
Blue Hawaiian Jello Shot Recipe
- 1 3-ounce package Berry Blue Jello (the small box)
- 1 cup boiling water (if you want extra tropical flavor, you can substitute pineapple juice for the water)
- ½ cup coconut rum (I used Malibu rum)
- ¼ cup Blue Curacao
- ¼ cup pineapple juice
- Pour the jello into the mixing bowl
- Add 1 cup of boiling water and stir until the crystals are all dissolved.
- Mix in the Malibu coconut rum, Blue Curacao, and pineapple juice.
- Pour the mixture into the jello shot cups
- Chill in the refrigerator for 2 to 4 hours until set.
- I like to use a mixing bowl with a spout*. It helps to prevent spills when you’re pouring the jello into the shot cups.
- Spreading out the jello shot cups* on a cookie sheet makes them easy to move into the fridge for chilling.
- Serving your jello shots with mini tasting spoons* gives people who don’t want to down them the traditional way another option.
Nutrition values are estimates only, using online calculators. Please verify using your own data.
Have you made our Blue Hawaiian jello shots recipe? Rate it in the comments section below.
Pin It So You Don't Forget It!
This post was originally published on June 16, 2018 but was updated with new content on March 8, 2023.
These are delicious!
Hello question. What if I use blue Hawaiian liqeour ?
Hi Lachandra…I didn’t know there was such a thing 🙂 So obviously, I haven’t tried it. But assuming it’s based on the flavors of the original drink, it seems like it would work.
What would be a good substitute for the pineapple juice?
Hi Jess…the pineapple juice is kind of what makes these Jello shots into a Blue Hawaiian. You can use water instead, but its not going to taste the same.
What could you replace the alcohol with? They sound amazing but unfortunately am currently pregnant.
Hi Kristin…I haven’t tried this so I don’t know exactly how it would taste, but I think you could use Coconut water instead of the Malibu rum and orange juice (no pulp) or orange-flavored kool aid instead of the blue curacao.
Hi, what if i use pineapple juice instead of the boiling water. Should i boil the pineapple juice?
Hi Crystal…yes, I think boiling the pineapple juice would work. I would stir it while it is on the stove and take it off the heat as soon as it starts to boil to make sure it doesn’t burn.
the jello boxes also say to add cold water to boiling water after the jello dissolves… do you do this step or instead of the 2 cups of cold water would you use pineapple juice?
Hi Jennifer…use pineapple juice instead of the cold water.
My jello didn’t set. I followed the exact recipe. Very upset about this. What a waste.
Hi Samantha…There are a few reasons why Jello shots don’t set: 1. The hot liquid wasn’t hot enough or the Jello wasn’t mixed long enough after the hot water was added so the Jello doesn’t dissolve completely, 2. Too much liquid was added (any more than 2 cups total and it won’t set) or 3. They weren’t chilled long enough or the refrigerator wasn’t cold enough. I have made the recipe successfully lots of times (as have many others) so I’m pretty sure it has the correct instructions.